STANDARD 4:  DIVERSITY

INTRODUCTION
DEMOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW
DEMOGRAPHICS OF LOCAL EDUCATION AUTHORITIES (LEA’S)
DEMOGRAPHICS OF UNIVERSITY OF SAINT FRANCIS
INDICATORS OF DIVERSITY IN TEACHER EDUCATION PROGRAMS
CURRICULAR EXPERIENCES
CANDIDATES’ EXPERIENCES WORKING WITH DIVERSE FACULTY
EXPERIENCES WORKING WITH DIVERSE CANDIDATES
CANDIDATES’ EXPERIENCES WORKING WITH DIVERSE STUDENTS IN P-12 SCHOOLS
CANDIDATES’ NON COURSE-RELATED EXPERIENCES WITH DIVERSE P-12 STUDENTS
SUMMARY

 

Standard 4: Diversity – The unit designs, implements, and evaluates curriculum and experiences for candidates to acquire and apply the knowledge, skills, and dispositions necessary to help all students learn. The experiences include working with diverse higher education and school faculty, diverse candidates, and diverse students in P-12 schools.


Introduction
Within the context of a homogeneous regional demographic profile, the Department provides its candidates with opportunities outside of the University classroom to interact with diverse populations within the region, coupling their interactions with diversity-related coursework in core education classes.
 

Demographic Overview
Ninety-percent of the University of Saint Francis student body originates in Fort Wayne, Allen County and counties in the northeast Indiana region, a region whose population is (83%) Caucasian-White, of Northern European-German extraction. Within the region, females outnumber males by three percent, while English is the dominant language spoken at home.

Median family income exceeds fifty thousand dollars annually. With a growing professional and services sector eclipsing the once-dominant manufacturing industry, the unemployment rate approximates the national average. While only seven percent of families classify as “living in poverty,” families with children under eighteen years of age comprise nearly twenty-five percent of poverty level families.

Demographics of Local Education Authorities (LEA’s)
The region’s population is predominantly Caucasian-White and English speaking, with a growing Hispanic sector. Its schools have experienced increases in their ethnic, linguistic, and socio-economic diversity. The Department’s candidates have taken advantage of the opportunities posed by these increasingly diverse populations through their field placements in practicum classes, methods classes, service learning opportunities, and student teaching in the region’s schools.


Demographics of University of Saint Francis
Candidates at both the undergraduate and advanced levels self-report information on race/ethnicity and gender as well as marital status and religion. Within a geographical region that is largely Caucasian-White-Northern European in racial/ethnic origin, the Department’s total minority enrollment has increased over the course of the past five years, from 2.5% to 3.8 %. With the exception of Asians, the number of candidates in all minority categories has trended upward as a percent of total Department enrollment, with the greatest percent increase occurring within the Hispanic population. African-American/Blacks continue to comprise the Department’s largest minority population (See Table 4.1)

Undergraduate and Graduate Teacher Education Candidate Enrollment by Diversity and Gender Category 1998-2002

Table 4.1

Year

African-

American/

Black (Non-Hispanic)

American

Indian/

Alaskan

Asian

Hispanic

Other

Total

Minority

Enrollment

Caucasian/

White (Non-Hispanic)

Male

Female

Total Depart-ment Enroll-ment

 

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

1998

3

1.30%

1

0.40%

0

0.00%

2

0.80%

23

9.60%

6

2.50%

211

87.90%

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

240

1999

5

1.80%

2

0.71%

3

1.10%

1

0.35%

34

12.10%

11

3.90%

237

84.00%

79

28.00%

203

72.00%

282

2000

9

3.10%

2

0.68%

3

1.00%

2

0.69%

35

10.00%

16

5.50%

241

82.50%

88

30.00%

204

70.00%

292

2001

9

2.80%

2

0.63%

2

0.63%

4

1.30%

56

17.70%

17

5.40%

243

77.00%

88

27.80%

228

72.20%

316

2002

6

1.90%

1

0.31%

1

0.31%

4

1.30%

60

18.90%

12

3.80%

246

77.40%

99

31.10%

219

68.90%

318

(Source:  University of Saint Francis Office of Student Services)


University-wide Economic and Religious Student Body Diversity
Although a majority of candidates declare Christianity as their religion, self-identified Roman Catholics account for fewer than thirty percent of student enrollment. A substantial number of candidates declined to indicate religious affiliation (Student Services).
 

Indicators of Diversity in Teacher Education Programs
Within the parameters of current candidate and faculty demographics, the Department provides candidates with diverse coursework and field experiences in urban, rural, and suburban settings, thus preparing them for success as public, parochial, and private school educators (Field Tracking Log Statistics).
 

Curricular Experiences
With the Conceptual Framework as its guide, the Department has refashioned its curriculum to provide academic courses that integrate diversity-centered knowledge, skills, and dispositions in a performance-based context. These courses ready candidates to implement adaptive educational approaches that serve a broad spectrum of candidates. Informed by the Franciscan ethos of community service, the academic offerings prepare candidates to work with all students, in an array of school settings. Overall, an adaptive, service-centered program constitutes the Department’s framework for preparing candidates to address the multifaceted needs of the increasingly diverse student populations within the region’s schools.

The revised 2002 academic program (referred to as the “new program”) provides coursework and field experiences that prepare candidates to better address the needs of diverse student populations. The new curriculum provides dually licensable programs in Elementary/Mild Intervention, Secondary/Mild Intervention, and an All-Grade Mild Intervention/Elementary/ Secondary, triple licensure program. Beginning in Fall of 2002 the Department incorporated five exceptional needs courses into the required program of study for all Teacher Education majors, thereby assuring that candidates meet all IPSB standards aimed at serving diverse student populations. The new required courses are Collaboration and Communication in Exceptional Needs (SPED 295), Elementary Methods for Exceptional Needs (SPED 218), Advanced Methods for Exceptional Needs (SPED 327), Behavior / Classroom Management (SPED 430), Advanced Practicum in Teacher Education (EDUC 301), and Laboratory Teaching with Children (ART 403-01, for Visual Art, K-12 candidates in lieu of EDUC 301).

The Department’s professional education core courses at both the undergraduate and graduate levels, listed in the section below, address the opportunities and challenges inherent in serving diverse populations.
 

Coursework Diversity: Undergraduate Preparation
Supporting the Conceptual Framework’s strands of Knowledge of Learner and Knowledge of Spiritual Self, the Department’s courses academically engage candidates at both the undergraduate and graduate levels with diversity-related issues by means of texts and related readings, audio-video media, class activities (including presentations and role playing), guest speakers, and outside assignments (including reflections and analyses). These coursework experiences directly expose candidates to issues commonly encountered by professionals in the P-12 classroom.

The following professional education courses address, to varying degrees, several key components of diversity—race, ethnicity, gender, exceptionalities, sexual orientation, and geography. The courses listed below are requirements in the undergraduate Teacher Education Programs, but additional requirements constitute part of the elementary, secondary, and exceptional needs programs, respectively.

EDUC 100 -

Introduction to Teacher Education

SPED 136 -

Introduction to Exceptionality

READ 200 -

Foundations of Reading Instruction

EDUC 201 -

Practicum in Teacher Education

SPED 237 -

Mild Disabilities/Interventions

EDUC 250 -

Educational Psychology & Measurement

EDUC 301 -

Advanced Practicum Teacher Education

READ 302 -

Methods/ Materials of Teaching Reading

SPED 347 -

Development of Competent Mild Disabled Youth

(Discontinued at Undergraduate Level as of Fall, 2002)

EDUC 391 -

Curriculum & Methods in Language Arts (Elementary)

(Discontinued at Undergraduate Level as of Fall, 2002)

EDUC 392 -

Curriculum & Methods in Social Studies (Elementary)

(Discontinued at Undergraduate Level as of Fall, 2002)

EDUC 393 -

Curriculum & Methods in Math (Elementary)

EDUC 394 -

Curriculum & Methods in Science (Elementary)

EDUC 425 -

Student Teaching Seminar

SPED 430 -

Behavior Management

In order to determine the emphasis being placed on diversity throughout the teacher education program at both the undergraduate and graduate levels, the Department surveyed all full-time and part-time professional education faculty regarding how many diversity-related coursework experiences were provided. The survey revealed that undergraduate courses present candidates with 274 experiences—ranging from text/readings, to technology/audio-visual, in-class activities, guest speakers, to out-of-class projects—that directly address issues related to the six diversity components. This survey was conducted in the Fall of 2002.

The survey data, displayed in Table 4.2 indicate that coursework experiences address all diversity components in the undergraduate program. However, those experiences related to race, ethnicity, exceptionalities, and gender, respectively, constitute the strongest focus of undergraduate professional education core courses. Conversely, coursework experiences related to sexual orientation and geographic diversity, respectively, constitute fewer experiences in the undergraduate professional education core.

Diversity Components as Percent of Total Coursework Experiences:

Undergraduate Professional Education Core Courses

   Table 4.2

Diversity Component

Percent of Diversity-Related Coursework Experiences

 

N

%

Race

54

19.7 %

Ethnicity

50

18.3%

Exceptionalities

49

17.9%

Gender

47

17.2%

Sexual Orientation

41

15.0 %

Geography

33

12.4%

TOTAL

                     274

   (Source:  Department of Education Faculty Survey, 2002)

Faculty survey data, as displayed in Table 4.3a indicate that, as a group, core courses in the undergraduate preparation program dedicate between 20% and 100% of their coursework experiences directly to diversity-related issues. That is, the coursework explicitly and directly addresses issues of race, ethnicity, gender, exceptionalities, sexual orientation, and geography. One course, such as Introduction to Exceptionality (EDUC 136), is, in its entirety, geared to coursework with diverse learning populations. Conversely, Student Teaching Seminar (EDUC 425) is designed to support candidates’ student teaching and, therefore, adapts to the varying needs that student teachers bring to the seminar setting.

Undergraduate Professional Education Core Courses

   Table 4.3a

Undergraduate Professional Education

Core Courses

Percent of Diversity- Related Coursework Experiences

EDUC 100—Introduction to Teacher Education

35%

SPED 136—Introduction to Exceptionality

100%

READ 200—Foundations of Reading Instruction

25%

EDUC 201—Intermediate Practicum in Teacher Education

25%

EDUC 250—Educational Psychology & Measurement

25%

EDUC 301—Advanced Practicum in Teacher Education

40%

READ 302—Methods & Materials for Teaching Reading for All Children

30%

SPED 347—Development of Competent Mild Disabled Youth

40%

EDUC 391—Curriculum & Methods in Language Arts (Elementary)

(as of Spring, 2003, EDUC 395)

20%

EDUC 392—Curriculum & Methods in Social Studies (Elementary)

(as of Spring, 2003, EDUC 395)

35%

EDUC 393— Curriculum & Methods in Math (Elementary)

40%

EDUC 394— Curriculum & Methods in Science (Elementary)

35%

EDUC 425—Student Teaching Seminar

20%

SPED 430— Behavior Management

75%

   (Source:  Department of Education Faculty Survey, 2002)

At the Graduate level, undergirding all Exceptional Needs and School Counseling core course and field experience competencies are the ability and desire to assist all students. Candidates demonstrate competency in these areas through mastery in selected core courses listed below (Tables 4.3b & c). These courses place particular emphasis on the skills necessary to provide services to diverse populations. Mastery of these courses includes demonstrated dispositional sensitivity to diversity and an orientation toward equity and fairness in the treatment of all persons. Candidates are routinely placed in school settings that provide opportunity and support for gaining experiences with and developing the skills necessary to provide culturally competent services to diverse ethnic and racial groups and exceptionalities.

Faculty who instruct School Counseling and Exceptional Needs candidates have demonstrated knowledge and experiences related to working with and preparing candidates to work with students from diverse groups. Similarly, clinical/supervising faculty who provide on-site supervision have training and experience in working with diverse populations.

School Counseling Core Courses-Graduate

  Table 4.3b

                         School Counseling Core Courses

Diversity-Related Coursework Experiences as a Percent

EDUC 553—Organization and Administration of Guidance Services

10%

PSYC 501—Advanced Human Growth and Development

15%

PSYC 518—Lifestyle and Career Counseling

25%

PSYC 522—Social and Cultural Issues in Counseling

100%

PSYC 530—Personality and Counseling Theories

30%

PSYC 535--Psychopathology

20%

PSYC 544—Counseling Skills

40%

PSYC 548—Group Processes in Counseling

20%

PSYC 578—Professional Orientation:  Ethical and Legal Issues in Counseling

30%

PSYC 579—Practicum in School Counseling

30-50%

PSYC 583—Internship in School Counseling

30-50%

  (Source:  Department of Psychology Faculty Survey, 2002)

Exceptional Needs Core Courses-Graduate

   Table 4.3c

                         Exceptional Needs Core Courses

Diversity-Related Coursework Experiences as a Percent

SPED 508—Methods for Elementary Exceptional Needs

15%

SPED 509—Advanced Methods

15%

SPED 510—Mild Disabilities

15%

SPED 513—Practicum

25-50%

SPED 527— Foundation in Exceptionality

40%

SPED 573—Collaboration and Communication

25%

SPED 540—Diagnostic & Prescriptive

25%

SPED 541—Classroom/Behavior Management

30%

SPED 550—Advanced Seminar

10%

   (Source: Department of Education Faculty Survey, 2002)


Other Diversity-Related Academic Experiences
The Department continues to intensify candidates’ understanding and appreciation of issues specifically focused on the preparation of teachers and school counselors through diversity-centered issues by a variety of means: professional written resources, invitations to guest speakers, participation in lectures, conference attendance, creation of action research projects for candidates, and establishment of an in-house lecture series for teacher preparation candidates.

In a quest to deepen their own theoretical and practical understanding of diversity issues, the Department faculty members have recently boosted the University library’s diversity-specific book holdings by 225 books, using as a resource the bibliography of Common Sense about Uncommon Knowledge: The Knowledge Bases for Diversity as a resource (Smith, 1998). These resources will further bolster the Department’s diversity-centered coursework.

In the classroom setting, several noteworthy guest speakers have addressed teacher candidates. Pastor Michael Latham, President of the Fort Wayne NAACP, familiarized candidates with the social-cultural-academic challenges facing African-American children in local schools. A Native American speaker, Jerry Farlee, a Lakota Indian living on the Cheyenne River Reservation, addressed Elementary Methods Social Studies candidates. Two high profile public school administrators have presented to candidates in professional education core classes. First, Ms. Laura Taliaferro, principal of Elmhurst High School, on the subject of social-emotional challenges p-12 students face in the schools, and numerous speakers on the topics related to student exceptionalities. Mr. Tom Smith, principal of one of the nation’s most culturally diverse high schools, South Side High School in Fort Wayne, joined a panel of area educators that spoke to student teachers.

Additionally, as part of their required program of study, Elementary/Mild Intervention have the choice of Introduction to Race and Ethnicity (SOC 135) or Minorities, Immigrants, and Migrants (SOCW 375). Secondary majors and all-grade exceptionalities and visual art take Introduction to Race and Ethnicity (SOC 135).

In addition to classroom-based work, two recent out-of-classroom experiences have encouraged candidates’ participation in diversity-centered settings. One event was an off-campus lecture in October by Dr. Janice Hale, author of Learning While Black, on the campus of Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne (IPFW). The second event, entitled “Race in Fort Wayne”, was a symposium sponsored by the Department of History and Social Studies, and was held on the University campus in November 2002.

Candidates in both Foundations of Reading Instruction (READ 200) and Methods & Materials for Teaching Reading for All Children (READ 302) have participated in Ruby Payne’s workshops on teaching children of poverty. The Reading classes then incorporated concepts and instructional strategies gleaned from Payne’s program into coursework. Subsequently, candidates referenced those ideas and teaching approaches to their field experiences in elementary school settings in the community. In addition to participating in the Ruby Payne Conference, candidates and faculty have attended Latinos Count: Community Summit, presented by DeSoto Translation & Marketing of Fort Wayne, in partnership with IPFW.

An Elementary Education Math Methods action-research project generated a special multicultural experience. Candidates hosted “Family Math Night”, a math-centered interactive event bringing together second grade parents, students, and teachers at Lindley Elementary School, a bi-lingual (English-Spanish) school whose population represents several minorities in Fort Wayne.

In the Spring of 2002, the Department budgeted for a series of lectures on issues of minority education that professional education professors have recently begun to incorporate into their courses. This series begins in the Spring of 2003, within the following targeted courses:
 

In Undergraduate Preparation: In Graduate Preparation:
Introduction to Teacher Education--EDUC 100 Mild Disabilities--SPED 510
Introduction to Exceptionality--SPED 136 Exceptional Needs Practicum--SPED 513
Practicum in Teacher Education--EDUC 201 Advanced Seminar--SPED 550
Advanced Practicum in Teacher Education--EDUC 301 Field Experiences in School Counseling--PSYC 579/583


Candidates’ Dispositional Behaviors and Diversity
The Department utilizes two assessment instruments, Assessment of Professional Potential and Dispositional Behaviors for Field Placement in undergraduate professional education courses, EDUC 100, SPED 136, and Assessment of Professional Potential in EDUC 250 to gauge candidates’ sensitivity to and competencies with diversity issues. The instruments, completed by professors and clinical/supervisory faculty, and candidates, are aligned with IPSB and INTASC Standards as well as the Department’s Conceptual Framework. In conjunction with these assessment instruments, professors conduct interviews with each beginning teacher candidate (through both EDUC 100 and SPED 136) to further assess potential issues, both positive and negative, related to their work with diverse student populations.

At the undergraduate level, EDUC 100, EDUC 201, EDUC 250, EDUC 301 and methods courses for secondary majors, professors and clinical/supervisory faculty continue to utilize Assessment of Professional Potential and Dispositional Behaviors for Field Placement to evaluate candidates in reference to diversity issues. Finally, Assessment of Professional Potential constitutes a key component of candidates’ application process for admission into the Teacher Education program as well as their application process for student teaching.

At the advanced graduate level, both professors and candidates complete Assessment of Professional Potential in several courses: SPED 510, SPED 513, and SPED 550. Additionally, applicants to the graduate program in Exceptional Needs and School Counseling must submit Assessment of Professional Potential from two professionals.
 

Service Learning
In keeping with the University’s Franciscan ethos of service to the community, and as reflected in both the spirit and substance of the Conceptual Framework, service learning is a prominent component of the Department. The service learning is aligned with the Conceptual Framework, and linked to both INTASC and IPSB standards, respectively. Since its inception in 1997, service learning has grown considerably, and presently boasts full faculty participation, reaches all teacher candidates, and dramatically affects change in the community. The overarching intent of service learning is to provide candidates with opportunities to convey academic knowledge, practice pedagogical skills, participate with diverse populations, and contribute to meeting community needs.

The concept of service learning as pedagogy is presented to all undergraduate Teacher Education candidates in the introductory level course, EDUC 100, through an undergraduate field experience in schools or community service organizations. The field intensive practicum course, EDUC 201, further develops both the theoretical and pedagogical models through development of content based lesson plans that incorporate service learning. With the pedagogical principles established, candidates then continue to develop and practice service learning through methods classes, including social studies, science, mathematics, mild disabilities, and, finally, student teaching.

Through service opportunities, candidates interact with the homeless, the hungry, refugees, and victims of violence, as well as with linguistic minorities. Additionally, candidates act as messengers of the service learning concept with their peers as well as with institutions at the local, regional levels. Both faculty assessments and candidate self-assessments reveal that service learning has developed high levels of candidates’ self-confidence, empowerment, and social conscience. Additional assessment of service learning skills and attitudes occurs through field assessment instruments, the portfolio review process, lesson plans, the community, and outreach log.

Over the course of the past five academic years, more than three dozen events and opportunities for participation have marked the Department’s involvement in service learning. Prominent accomplishments include: a $2,500 grant received from the National Service Learning in Teacher Education Partnership (two years), participation in the National Conference for Service Learning (two years), candidate grants, candidate awards, collaboration with Northrop High School Teaching Academy, membership in the Campus Compact, the “Math Is Everywhere” program, the “Stellar Story Tellers” program, and student presentations at the 2002 “Campus Compact: First Student Conference for Service Learning” at Ball State University, Spring, 2002.

Finally, in 2002, one the Department’s faculty was selected by AACTE and National Service Learning Partnership in Teacher Education as one of 50 national educators to attend the latter’s national conference.
 

Candidates’ Experiences Working with Diverse Faculty
The Department’s full-time, part-time, and adjunct faculty includes two Native Americans. Beyond the Department itself, candidates have the opportunity to work with diverse faculty through their classes across various University departments. The University of Saint Francis faculty counts as its members two Hispanics, two Native Americans, three East Indian-Americans, and two Pacific-Islanders (E-mail Survey of Department Chairs, December, 2002).

In addition to the on-campus faculty, candidates work in P-12 public and parochial schools with minority certified personnel. Teacher education candidates have numerous opportunities to interact with minority school faculty through practicum, internship, and methods courses, and finally, student teaching (Table 3.3a – c, P-12 minority data).

The Department recognizes the need to recruit minority faculty. As an Equal Opportunity Employer, the University as a whole continues in its endeavors to recruit diverse faculty members through both broad-based regional and national media advertising and targeted minority media advertising. These advertisement avenues are supplemented by contacts with professional colleagues in the field. The Department itself has expanded its efforts in minority recruiting through online professional search sources, postings in ethnically targeted professional journals, direct mailing to diverse higher education institutions with advanced degree/doctoral programs.

In recognition of the importance of diversity, both the University’s Strategic Plan and the Department’s Business/Marketing Plan emphasize the need to develop a recruitment and retention plan for minority faculty, staff, and students. The Department and University are working in tandem through a subcommittee charged with creating a viable diversity plan. The Vice President of Academic Affairs, the Human Resource/Affirmative Action Officer, and a member of the Department of Education have joined with a member of the University Advisory Board whose expertise lies in facilitating institutional diversity. These members have consulted with a representative from a local state university that is currently implementing a diversity plan.
 

Experiences Working with Diverse Candidates
To provide its candidates with interactions with diverse candidates the Department relies upon the diversity composition within the student body of the University as a whole. The Department endeavors to provide opportunities for teacher education candidates to interact with diverse populations on and off campus. Examples of these opportunities include: assignment of group projects, required service learning experiences, and attendance of local, state, and national conferences.  
 

Department Initiative for Increasing Candidate Diversity
In March of 2002, the Department formed an ad hoc group of faculty and administrators whose mission is “to encourage a trustful, affirming community by promoting the recruitment, retention, and graduation of teacher candidates from diverse populations in the University’s Teacher Education Program.” The rationale for the group’s formation is, “the lack of diversity representation among University graduates [that] concerns the Department, the Univers