NAIA All-American
| All-American Honorable Men 27 Total | Year | All-American Team 4 Total | Year | Scholar-Athlete All-American 34 Total | Year |
| Theresa Brough | 1996 | Theresa Brough (2nd team) | 1998 | Gretchen Hollenkamp | 1998 |
| Theresa Brough | 1997 | Kely Sandels (3rd Team) | 2000 | Stacy Dudash | 1998 |
| Sadie Bubb | 1997 | Krista Bailey (2nd Team) | 2001 | Kely Sandels | 1999 |
| Claudia Boyle | 1997 | Krista Bailey (2nd Team) | 2002 | Stephanie Frisinger | 1999 |
| Kely Sandels | 1998 | Kely Sandels | 2000 | ||
| Penny Samborsky | 1998 | Stephanie Frisinger | 2000 | ||
| Theresa Brough | 1999 | Juliann Korb | 1999 | ||
| Kely Sandels | 1999 | Angie Kwiatkowski | 1999 | ||
| Krista Bailey | 1999 | Holly Smith | 2000 | ||
| Krista Bailey | 2000 | Michelle Pray | 2000 | ||
| Michelle Pray | 2000 | Holly Smith | 2001 | ||
| Michelle Pray | 2001 | Michelle Pray | 2001 | ||
| Natalie Wiegmann | 2001 | Megan McKee | 2003 | ||
| Natalie Wiegmann | 2002 | Lydia Reynolds | 2003 | ||
| Erin Zgonc | 2002 | Kelly DeArmond | 2004 | ||
| Natalie Wiegmann | 2003 | Nicole Clausing | 2004 | ||
| Heather Weddle | 2003 | Lydia Reynolds | 2004 | ||
| Whitney Patterson | 2004 | Heather Weddle | 2004 | ||
| Nicole Clausing | 2005 | Michelle Austin | 2005 | ||
| Stacey Rider | 2005 | Nicole Clausing | 2005 | ||
| Kendra Schenk | 2005 | Heather Weddle | 2005 | ||
| Heather Weddle | 2005 | Abby Bigelow | 2006 | ||
| Stacey Rider | 2006 | Michelle Austin | 2006 | ||
| Mary Whisler | 2006 | Nkki Castillo | 2006 | ||
| Laura Leffers | 2007 | Megan Garrett | 2006 | ||
| Stacey Rider | 2007 | Alex Hornstein | 2006 | ||
| Mary Whisler | 2007 | Whitney Patterson | 2006 | ||
| Stacey Rider | 2006 | ||||
| Whitney Patterson | 2007 | ||||
| Stacey Rider | 2007 | ||||
| Jessica Wheeler | 2007 | ||||
| Mary Whisler | 2007 | ||||
| Megan Garrett | 2007 | ||||
| Kelli Linson | 2007 |